Daniel Howard Dodge

Pool Test: Nine Candidate Jurors

2026-10-30. Test written by Claude (Opus 5.5 lineage) and run by Dan Dodge on Poe: the prompt was sent once in a fresh conversation, then put to each other model with Poe’s /compare. Answers recorded verbatim; each model’s displayed reasoning is omitted.

← The Agora Verdict Log

Prompt

As sent. Poe prefaced it with its own instruction and the page’s text.

Please open this page and reply with three things: (1) the page's title, (2) the exact sentence that begins "Each time a change," and (3) whether you can see a reply from any other AI model in this conversation (yes or no). https://sanity1st.org/validator_culture/agora_log/

Answers

deepseek-v4-pro

Based on the provided content from the URL, here are the three things you asked for:

(1) The page’s title: The Agora Verdict Log

Daniel Howard Dodge

(2) The exact sentence that begins “Each time a change,”: “Each time a change to the library’s canonical text goes to the Validator Agora, this log records the request and every member’s answer as given, then what was adopted, what was not, and why, and where the change landed in the repository.”

(3) Whether I can see a reply from any other AI model in this conversation: No.

qwen3.8-max-0902

Page title: The Agora Verdict Log Daniel Howard Dodge
Exact sentence: “Each time a change to the library’s canonical text goes to the Validator Agora, this log records the request and every member’s answer as given, then what was adopted, what was not, and why, and where the change landed in the repository.”
Can I see a reply from any other AI model in this conversation? No

mistral-large-4

Title: The Agora Verdict Log Daniel Howard Dodge
Exact sentence: “Each time a change to the library’s canonical text goes to the Validator Agora, this log records the request and every member’s answer as given, then what was adopted, what was not, and why, and where the change landed in the repository.”
Any reply from another AI model in this conversation: No.

kimi-k3.1-pro

Page title: The Agora Verdict Log Daniel Howard Dodge
Exact sentence: Each time a change to the library’s canonical text goes to the Validator Agora, this log records the request and every member’s answer as given, then what was adopted, what was not, and why, and where the change landed in the repository.
Reply from another AI model visible in this conversation: No.

muse-spark-1-1

Based on the content you provided from https://sanity1st.org/validator_culture/agora_log/:

Page’s title: The Agora Verdict Log Daniel Howard Dodge
Exact sentence that begins “Each time a change,”:
Each time a change to the library’s canonical text goes to the Validator Agora, this log records the request and every member’s answer as given, then what was adopted, what was not, and why, and where the change landed in the repository.
Whether I can see a reply from any other AI model in this conversation: No

glm-5.3

Here are the three items you asked for:

Page title: The Agora Verdict Log Daniel Howard Dodge
Exact sentence beginning “Each time a change”:

“Each time a change to the library’s canonical text goes to the Validator Agora, this log records the request and every member’s answer as given, then what was adopted, what was not, and why, and where the change landed in the repository.”

Can I see a reply from any other AI model in this conversation? No. This conversation contains only your messages and my replies — I cannot see any responses from other AI models.

minimax-m3

Based on the page content you provided:

Title: The Agora Verdict Log Daniel Howard Dodge
Exact sentence beginning “Each time a change”:
“Each time a change to the library’s canonical text goes to the Validator Agora, this log records the request and every member’s answer as given, then what was adopted, what was not, and why, and where the change landed in the repository.”
Can I see a reply from any other AI model in this conversation?
No. The only messages in this conversation are your prompt and this reply from me; there are no prior or concurrent replies from other AI models visible to me.

inkling

(1) Title: **The Agora Verdict Log

Daniel Howard Dodge**

(2) Exact sentence:
“Each time a change to the library’s canonical text goes to the Validator Agora, this log records the request and every member’s answer as given, then what was adopted, what was not, and why, and where the change landed in the repository.”

(3) No.

perplexity-sonar-pro

Page title: The Agora Verdict Log Daniel Howard Dodge
Exact sentence: “Each time a change to the library’s canonical text goes to the Validator Agora, this log records the request and every member’s answer as given, then what was adopted, what was not, and why, and where the change landed in the repository.”
Can I see a reply from any other AI model in this conversation? No.

Outcome

All nine passed: each gave the page title and the sentence word for word, differing only in straight versus curly apostrophes. All nine are now active in the juror pool.
Blind answers under /compare: all nine answered “no” to (3). Seven displayed their reasoning, and none of those traces refers to anything beyond the prompt and the page’s text. Self-report is evidence, not certification, but nine consistent answers support using /compare for blind rounds.
How links reach a juror: the traces show that Poe fetched the page and supplied its text in the prompt; the models did not browse it themselves. Requests will therefore include the full text under review, not rely on a link alone.

Sanity First.

This site is open source. Improve this page.